
78703 · West Austin · An honest guide
Is Tarrytown a Good Place to Live?
The real pros, the trade-offs most listings leave out, and an honest read on who the neighborhood actually fits.
The short answer
Is Tarrytown a good place to live?
Yes, for buyers who want a quiet, historic, tree-canopied neighborhood about three miles from downtown Austin, with Lake Austin access and top-rated schools. The main trade-off is cost: Tarrytown is one of Austin's most expensive areas, with a median home price well into seven figures, and it is car-oriented rather than walkable.
Tarrytown living, at a glance
The quick facts
Closed sales, trailing 12 months (Redfin, Homes.com)
Roughly 5 to 10 minutes by car to downtown and UT
Highly rated; verify the zone for any address
One of Austin's oldest planned neighborhoods
Most adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher (neighborhood data)
Well above the Austin average; among the city's priciest areas
Why people love it
The case for Tarrytown
Central, close-in location
Tarrytown sits about three miles west of downtown Austin and the University of Texas, a short drive to work, the lake, and the city, while staying quiet and residential.
Lake Austin lifestyle
The neighborhood runs to the east shore of Lake Austin, giving residents boating, paddling, and waterfront access that is rare this close to a downtown.
Historic character and big trees
Streets of 1920s and 1930s cottages, Tudors, and mature live oaks give Tarrytown a settled, canopied feel, on lots that run larger than most close-in Austin neighborhoods.
Top-rated schools
Most of the neighborhood is zoned to well-regarded Austin ISD schools, led by Casis Elementary, a major draw for families.
Established, invested community
Residents are highly educated and tend to hold for the long term, which supports stability and, historically, durable home values.
Architectural variety
From restored cottages to modern estates, the housing stock is unusually varied for a single neighborhood, so there are several ways in depending on budget and taste.
The honest trade-offs
What to weigh before you move
No neighborhood is perfect. Here is the straight version of the trade-offs, so you can decide with clear eyes.
It is expensive
This is the honest headline trade-off. Tarrytown is among Austin's priciest neighborhoods, with a median sale well into seven figures and a cost of living above the city average. Estimate the carrying cost with the property tax calculator.
It is car-oriented
Despite being close-in, most errands require a car. There are walkable pockets, parks, and lake trails, but this is not a dense, walk-everywhere district.
Older homes can need work
Much of the charm is vintage, which means some homes carry renovation or update costs. Budget for condition, and read value lot by lot. The buying guide covers teardown and rebuild economics.
Inventory is thin and competitive
It is a small neighborhood with low turnover, so well-priced homes move quickly and the best ones often trade off market. Being prepared matters.
Quiet, not nightlife
Tarrytown is residential by design. Downtown and the West Sixth district are a few minutes away, but the neighborhood itself is calm, which most residents consider a feature.
The honest fit
Who Tarrytown is right for
A great fit if
- You want a quiet, established neighborhood close to downtown and UT
- Schools, large lots, and mature trees matter to you
- You value Lake Austin access and a long-term address
- Your budget fits a seven-figure home and higher carrying costs
Maybe look elsewhere if
- You need a walk-everywhere, nightlife-dense location
- You are looking for an entry-level price point
- You want brand-new construction in a master-planned community
- You prefer newer homes with no renovation considerations
Still weighing it against other West Austin areas? Compare Tarrytown and Westlake, or see the full neighborhood guide.
Living in Tarrytown
Questions people ask
- Is Tarrytown an expensive place to live?
- Yes. Tarrytown is one of Austin's more expensive neighborhoods. The median home price runs well into seven figures, roughly $1.5 million to $1.65 million in closed sales over the trailing year, and the local cost of living sits above the Austin average. Property taxes in 78703 run roughly 1.8 to 2.0 percent of assessed value before exemptions. This is general information, not tax or financial advice.
- Is Tarrytown a good place to live for families?
- Many families choose Tarrytown for its schools, quiet streets, parks, and large lots. Most of the neighborhood is zoned to Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle School, and Austin High School in Austin ISD. Attendance zones vary by exact address and can change, so confirm the zone for a specific home with the district.
- Is Tarrytown walkable?
- Partly. Tarrytown is primarily car-oriented, and most errands require a vehicle. That said, it is close-in, about three miles from downtown Austin and UT, with walkable pockets, parks, and lake trails. It suits buyers who want a quiet residential setting rather than a dense, walk-everywhere district.
- Is Tarrytown a safe neighborhood?
- Tarrytown is generally regarded as one of Austin's established, quiet residential neighborhoods. Safety still varies block by block, so review current crime data through the Austin Police Department or a neighborhood data source for any specific address before deciding.
- How far is Tarrytown from downtown Austin?
- About three miles, roughly 5 to 10 minutes by car west of downtown Austin and the University of Texas, depending on traffic and your exact street.
- Is Tarrytown a good investment?
- Tarrytown has historically shown durable values, supported by limited supply, large lots, mature trees, and zoning to highly regarded schools. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and outcomes depend on the specific property and your timeline. Evaluate any purchase against real closed comparable sales.
Published November 5, 2026· By Luke Allen, TREC #788149
Related
Continue through Tarrytown
Work with Luke
Thinking about a move to Tarrytown?
Tell Luke what matters most, schools, the lake, a quiet street, or a specific budget, and he will tell you honestly whether Tarrytown fits and what is realistically available.

Luke Allen
Licensed Texas REALTOR, TREC #788149
Austin Marketing + Development Group